Matthew Loftus is a doctor. In "Does the Body Really Keep the Score?" he contends that there is a current tendency to "medicalize" far too many non-medical conditions, leading to a "loss of agency" in those diagnosed. I have excerpted a few passages and, by doing so, left out the research he used, but not, I think, oversimplifying his conclusions:
The idea of psychological trauma, from the Greek word for “wound,” has undergone more than one transformation over recent decades. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, now in its fifth edition, initially limited the diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) to people who had undergone “an event that is outside the range of usual human experience and that would be markedly distressing to almost anyone.” The fourth edition changed this to events that were life-threatening, and the fifth edition now says that a person can develop PTSD after learning about a trauma that their close friends or relatives have experienced.This expansion of PTSD’s definition is just one example of medicalization: taking nonmedical problems and making them medical, adding a clinical dimension where once there was none. .......[M]edicalizing normal life experiences and judging institutions by their perceived mental health impact lead to a loss of agency as people define themselves by diagnoses and view their entire lives through the lens of being mentally ill. ....Expanding the definition of trauma can be powerful because it gives people a story that explains how they got to where they are—regardless of whether or not that story is true. We can’t always draw a hard-and-fast line to say “this is psychological trauma” while “that is just a very stressful experience” because stress and trauma are more of a continuum than two distinct categories. However, what we see now is an attempt to maximize the number of things considered as trauma.......[H]aving a mental health diagnosis has become a status symbol in some cultures, particularly among young people. More importantly, though, medicalization and diagnosis-as-identity give people a sense in which their pain is legitimate and legible to others, especially in contexts where mental health disorders are romanticized. If a teenager notices that supportive online communities cluster around people with diagnoses of depression or PTSD, they may self-diagnose so that others can affirm that their emotional turmoil is real, even if that turmoil doesn’t meet the definition for any mental disorder. ....Medicalization, therapy culture, and the misuse of trauma studies are harmful because they encourage people to think of themselves as helpless victims, defining their entire lives through the lens of a mental illness and using the language of “trauma response” (alongside a great deal of other therapy-speak) to avoid accountability. ....When people who don’t really need therapy or psychiatry clog up the patient rolls, it becomes harder for people who are suffering from serious mental illnesses to get the help that they need.How do we make this better? The first step is getting rid of mental health awareness programs in schools. More and more evidence is accumulating that these programs actually make kids psychologically sicker by encouraging them to reframe their normal experiences as symptoms of a mental illness. .......[W]e should actively reject any psychological framework that encourages people to diminish their own agency. Good therapeutic practice for any mental illness aids suffering individuals by helping them see how they can change their own thoughts and responses to whatever is happening to them. Time-tested therapeutic practices like cognitive-behavioral therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy are designed around accepting that while we cannot change what others do, we can accept reality and modify our own behavior in order to feel better. A worldview that tells people they can’t push themselves to overcome or mature through suffering is a worldview that will make people less capable of flourishing. .... (more)

No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are moderated. I will gladly approve any comment that responds directly and politely to what has been posted.